Breastfeeding mothers clutch at their tender nipples during the first few weeks and wonder whether they will ever get any respite. Bottle fed babies show such an aptitude for sucking that their parents feel it would only be right to allow them to do it for longer. Even the staunchest anti dummy-ites out there have sat up many a sleepless night questioning their choices because put simply - babies love to suck. Babies seem to have forgotten to read the manual that amongst other things, told them how to self soothe. They love to suck and appear content (finally!) when they are merrily sucking on a bruised boob or bottle test. After feeding they just can't settle without a little something something, surely they need help? Can a dummy be your answer?
Parents often wonder whether they need a dummy. Will their little ones eventually find their little thumbs? And what do we do when they need to be weaned off their dummies or thumbs?
The pacifier culture in America appears to be more entrenched than this side of the pond. A good friend of mine was told by her (American) mother that she was mad not to use one with her newborn and being the good daughter she is, promptly offered a dummy. Not for nothing, her little girl is the most chilled baby in our friendship circle. I'm not sure I have ever heard her cry for longer than a few seconds. She's put herself to sleep since day one with her dummy and can pretty much nod off anywhere. My little darling on the other hand has been in a love hate relationship with her thumb since she was born. Each time her thumb let her down we had to deal with the fallout. It was like helping a love sick teenager through a breakup.
I couldn't help but question during one of my many sleepless nights, why the dummy was so popular amongst the yanks but still viewed with caution over here. Is it our stiff upper lip that can't quite grasp the dummy? Or perhaps dummies are just as accepted in the UK but the sheer volume of babies in the U.S. make it seem like they are on the up there.
Of course I turned to my very good friend Web Based Research. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) babies up to 1 year old should use dummies at bedtime and nap time. They found that dummies reduced the risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS). Clearly this is something new parents would be delighted to hear!
Although when asking my friends over the other side of the Atlantic if they knew about this, I was shocked to hear most had no clue at all. If I were a dummy manufacturer, this would be my main advertising point. It would probably the only feature of my advert.
Actually the main reason for dummy usage amongst my American pals is exactly the same as my British friends. Dummies, quite literally, pacify our babies! We coo and ahh over little loves as they make sucky noises in their sleep. We giggle as our little ones hungrily forage for their fingers or thumbs to suck. But no mother delights as they desperately look for their nipple for the umpteenth time that hour. Let's face it, something needs to stop that baby sucking!!
That shrill sound of our babies crying for no apparent reason makes even the calmest of parents cringe. Babies are born with a sucking reflex. Sadly they didn't get the memo that they don't need to cry when they can't.
What should new parents do? Wait for a thumb to magically make friends with their baby's mouth? Offer a dummy and pray it makes a difference? Or just ride it out?
Watching my little one look for her thumb in desperation gave me hope that one day she would find it. My DH and I spent many a night praying that she would make the connection. At one point I considered putting an advert on
match.com for her. "Wanted, one tiny thumb looking for love with a little mouth desperate to find its one true love." Yes - I was tired.
I listened as my wonderful grandmother informed me that I needed to give my little girl a dummy. Without it, I found out, she would never be happy. That same grandmother - who had three children over 60 years ago - was not shy about letting me know I should give up breastfeeding too. According to her it wasn't worth the hassle.
My sister also had two successful dummy tales. Babies who didn't need to be taught how to self soothe because their dummy did it for them. My little darling on the other hand, had no interest in falling asleep anywhere but my boob.
I watched my angel desperately seeking her thumb and felt that if she only found it life would be so much better.
I should be honest, things at that point were not a bed of roses. In fact a bed of any kind was something I wasn't seeing much of at all. Having spent the best part of 6 weeks letting my baby get rocked; fed; cuddled or walked to sleep I decided to try my hand at sleep training. It was not going well. Hours were spent shush patting til the cows came home. Money went straight into Euan the Sheep's pocket as he arrived at our house to gallantly save the day, one annoying tune at a time. I even stopped going out during her lunchtime nap in the hope that I could train her to sleep at home.
The results were bleak. I was tired, irritable and fed up. She probably felt the same although was too polite to say "Mommy what the f**k are you doing?"
DH and I put a time limit on the thumb. We put a break clause in the thumb's lease of the mouth. If that pesky thumb hadn't found its way to our beautiful baby's mouth by the end of the month we were sending it packing and welcoming in Dame Dummy.
Just the act of standing firm with the thumb made me felt better. We had a renewed sense of purpose as we prepared ourselves for Dame Dummy to move in.
And then it happened. Quite unexpectedly, very much out of the blue. One evening our little lady had a little tummy upset. On her way to her bath she started crying and no amount of cuddling would calm her. It transpired that she was experiencing her first bout of diarrhoea. The poor lass was distraught, wailing and wailing away until something remarkable happened. In her angst she finally made her connection. The thumb actually found her mouth! A happy match was made in the bathroom. Quite outstanding really, poo dunnit!
After that I would love to say it's been plain sailing but it would be a lie. As she has struggled to keep a hold of her little thumb I have questioned our decision to hold off the dummy usage time and time again. You can't pop a thumb back in their mouth and tempting as it may seem, you can't glue a thumb in so there is very little to do when they loose it. Although at least you don't need to sterilise a thumb.
Many a night we have woken to the sounds of screams as she wakes hoping to find her thumb where she left it. Overcome with sadness that her thumb would leave her whilst she was sleeping, it was once again up to us to pick up the pieces. I considered yet again bringing in Dame Dummy to save the day.
Three weeks later I feel that we have made headway. Her thumb still pops out and she still gets disproportionately angry to find her palm instead of her thumb, but it's getting better. I often wake to that blissful sound of her sucking away, gently soothing herself back to sleep.
I have no idea how I will ever get her to stop sucking her thumb. As one who never quite found my own and apparently gave up looking quite early on, I have no experience here. Sadly their is no Thumb Fairy to help kids get over sucking their thumbs, although I hear the Dummy Fairy can be very strict about removing her dummies so maybe a Thumb Fairy will visit us after all.
For now I am not questioning what happens next. On the contrary for keeping my little lady calm I am considering buying her thumb a gift! Despite taking immense pleasure in the fact that I not only have a very happy little girl but I also didn't have to give her a dummy to make her happy, I haven't broken the news to my grandma. I think she would be more upset to find she was wrong than my little lady would be to find her thumb removed.
Some victories, however large, are best left silent!